The uncle, entrusted with temporary guardianship, allegedly failed the teen—whose death advocates say could have been prevented—during a state-sanctioned outing.

Fatal Visit Approved by State Child Services

July 11, 2025: Seventeen-year-old Caden Cantrelle died after being permitted by Tennessee’s Department of Children’s Services (DCS) to spend two days with his uncle, Victor “Jerry” Carver III, who had a significant criminal history. Caden never returned from the visit, prompting an investigation that led to Carver’s immediate arrest and manslaughter charges. Awareness of the uncle’s past crimes came only after Caden’s disappearance.

“Prevented Him from Having a Chance”

Caden’s court-appointed legal advocate, Stacie Odeneal, forcefully criticized the decision to allow the visit, stating, “We as a system prevented him from having a chance.” Community advocates echoed concern, saying transparency and child safety should have prevailed over reunification based on family ties.

Uncle’s Criminal Past and Failed Oversight

Carver, 37, has a criminal record dating back to 2007, including a guilty plea for attempted aggravated assault. DCS is under scrutiny for granting access to a minor to a guardian without proper oversight, particularly someone with known violent tendencies. No police report or missing-person notification was filed by the uncle after Caden vanished.

Public Safety and Policy Concerns

This tragic case has triggered broader calls for reform in DCS protocols nationwide. Critics argue that the agency must thoroughly vet caregivers’ records and require ongoing supervision—never offering unsupervised access when criminal history exists. That clarity and diligence might be the difference between life and needless loss.

Caden’s death at the hands of his uncle—approved by state guardianship—has sparked outrage and calls for systemic change. Advocates and legal authorities alike warn this fatal mistake exposed a minor to grave danger that could have been avoided with proper oversight and background checks.