Brad Pitt may join The Batman: Part II as a chilling new antagonist linked to Arkham

Brad Pitt Could Be Heading to Gotham

December 13, 2025: Brad Pitt is reportedly in discussions to join The Batman: Part II, potentially taking on a major villain role in Matt Reeves’ highly anticipated sequel. According to industry buzz, the Oscar-winning actor is being considered for Dr. Arkham, a character deeply rooted in Gotham’s psychological underbelly.

HOLR has the latest news as casting speculation fuels excitement around the next chapter of the Batman saga.

Who Is Dr. Arkham?

Dr. Amadeus Arkham is the founder of Arkham Asylum and, in several comic interpretations, a tragic figure whose descent into madness blurs the line between healer and villain. The character’s psychological depth and moral ambiguity align closely with the gritty, noir-inspired tone Reeves established in The Batman.

If cast, Pitt would be positioned to deliver a cerebral, unsettling performance rather than a traditional action-heavy antagonist.

Why Brad Pitt Makes Sense for the Role

Brad Pitt’s recent career choices have leaned toward complex, character-driven roles rather than standard blockbusters. His ability to portray controlled menace, intelligence, and internal conflict makes him a compelling fit for a figure like Dr. Arkham.

HOLR breaks down the story here: Reeves’ Batman universe prioritizes atmosphere, psychology, and corruption over spectacle—exactly the terrain where Pitt excels.

What This Means for The Batman: Part II

The sequel is expected to expand Gotham’s institutional corruption, exploring how systems meant to protect the city instead help destroy it. Introducing Dr. Arkham would deepen that theme, shifting focus from street-level crime to the mental and moral decay beneath Gotham’s surface.

Robert Pattinson is set to return as Batman, alongside other familiar faces, as the sequel reportedly pushes the Dark Knight into even murkier territory.

Fan Reaction and Industry Buzz

News of Pitt’s possible involvement sparked immediate fan reaction online, with many calling it one of the most inspired DC casting rumors in years. Some fans speculate that Dr. Arkham could serve as a connective figure for future villains, laying groundwork for a broader rogues’ gallery.

HOLR has the latest news as anticipation continues to build around the sequel’s evolving cast.

No Official Confirmation—Yet

While talks are reportedly in early stages, neither Warner Bros. nor Matt Reeves has commented publicly on the rumor. Scheduling, script details, and final negotiations are still in flux.

If confirmed, Brad Pitt’s addition would mark one of the most high-profile castings in the franchise and signal just how ambitious The Batman: Part II aims to be.

A Darker Gotham on the Horizon

Whether or not the deal moves forward, the rumor alone underscores the creative direction of Reeves’ Batman universe—one that attracts top-tier talent and prioritizes depth over formula.