Composer’s blunt reaction to film adaptation resurfaces

Andrew Lloyd Webber Criticizes Cats

April 01, 2026 – Andrew Lloyd Webber has once again made headlines after candidly expressing his strong dislike for the 2019 film adaptation of Cats, describing it as “appalling.” The composer, who created the original stage musical, revealed that his reaction to the film was so intense that he ended up buying a dog shortly after watching it.

The remark, both humorous and revealing, has reignited conversations about the film’s troubled reception and its stark contrast to the success of the original musical.

Image Credit: Universal Pictures / courtesy Everett Collection

A Film That Fell Short of Expectations

When Cats was released in 2019, it faced widespread criticism from both audiences and critics. Despite boasting a high-profile cast and significant anticipation, the film struggled with its visual effects, tone, and overall execution.

For many fans of the stage production, the adaptation failed to capture the magic and theatrical charm that made Cats a global phenomenon. Lloyd Webber’s comments echo a sentiment that has persisted since the film’s release.

From Stage Success to Screen Controversy

The original Cats musical, based on T.S. Eliot’s poetry, became one of the most successful stage productions in history. Its innovative choreography, memorable songs, and unique storytelling captivated audiences worldwide.

The transition from stage to screen, however, proved challenging. The film’s attempt to reinterpret the material using advanced visual effects resulted in a style that many viewers found unsettling rather than engaging.

Image Credit: Universal Pictures

A Personal Reaction That Stands Out

Lloyd Webber’s decision to buy a dog after watching the film has become a widely shared anecdote, symbolizing his dissatisfaction in a lighthearted yet pointed way. The story reflects not only his disappointment but also his personal connection to the original work.

As the creator of Cats, Lloyd Webber’s perspective carries significant weight, making his criticism particularly noteworthy within the entertainment industry.

The Legacy of Cats

Despite its negative reception, the film remains a topic of discussion, often cited as an example of how ambitious adaptations can miss the mark. Over time, it has even developed a kind of cult status, with some viewers revisiting it out of curiosity or appreciation for its unconventional approach.

The contrast between the enduring success of the stage musical and the film’s reception highlights the complexities of adapting beloved works across mediums.

Image Credit: Universal Pictures

Hollywood Adaptations Under the Microscope

The Cats film is part of a broader trend in which stage musicals are adapted for the big screen. While some adaptations have been successful, others have struggled to translate the unique qualities of live theater into a cinematic format.

Lloyd Webber’s comments serve as a reminder of the challenges involved in preserving the essence of a production while reimagining it for a different audience.

Fan Reactions to Lloyd Webber’s Comments

Fans have responded to Lloyd Webber’s remarks with a mix of amusement and agreement. Many have shared their own critiques of the film, while others appreciate the humor in his reaction.

The story has also contributed to the ongoing cultural conversation surrounding Cats, keeping the film relevant years after its release.

Image Credit: Arturo Holmes/Getty Images

The Role of Creator Perspective

When creators speak openly about adaptations of their work, it often adds a new dimension to public discourse. Lloyd Webber’s candidness provides insight into how deeply creators can feel about the interpretation of their creations.

His comments highlight the importance of maintaining artistic integrity while navigating the complexities of large-scale productions.

Final Thoughts

Andrew Lloyd Webber’s blunt critique of the Cats film—and his memorable decision to buy a dog afterward—captures the enduring disconnect between the beloved stage musical and its controversial adaptation. While the film may continue to spark debate, Lloyd Webber’s reaction underscores the challenges of translating iconic works into new formats.

In the end, the story serves as both a humorous anecdote and a reflection of the high expectations that come with adapting a cultural classic.

FAQs

Q1: What did Andrew Lloyd Webber say about the Cats film?
He described it as “appalling” and expressed strong dissatisfaction with the adaptation.

Q2: Why did he buy a dog?
He humorously revealed that watching the film led him to seek comfort by getting a dog.

Q3: When was the Cats film released?
The film was released in 2019.

Q4: Was the film successful?
It received largely negative reviews and struggled to meet expectations.

Q5: Is the stage musical still popular?
Yes, Cats remains one of the most successful and enduring stage productions worldwide.