Brad Pitt is reportedly in talks to join The Batman: Part II as a potential villain, with early reports suggesting he may play Dr. Arkham in the highly anticipated sequel.

Pitt Eyed for Major DC Villain Role

December 12, 2025: Brad Pitt may be heading to Gotham. The Oscar-winning actor is reportedly in early talks to join Matt Reeves’ The Batman: Part II as a major villain — with insiders pointing to Dr. Arkham as the character he is being considered for. While nothing has been finalized, the possibility of Pitt joining Robert Pattinson’s dark, grounded Bat-universe has ignited massive excitement across the DC fandom.

Who Is Dr. Arkham?

Dr. Amadeus Arkham — often known simply as Dr. Arkham — is the founder of the infamous Arkham Asylum. In several comic interpretations, he gradually descends into madness, blurring the line between healer and villain. The character would fit seamlessly into the psychological tone Reeves established in The Batman, which emphasized corruption, mental illness, and Gotham’s systemic decay.

Casting Pitt as Dr. Arkham would give Reeves a powerful performer capable of delivering a layered, unsettling antagonist.

HOLR has the latest updates as casting rumors continue to shape expectations for the sequel.

Why Pitt’s Casting Would Be a Game-Changer

Brad Pitt joining DC would mark one of his most high-profile blockbuster roles in years. Known for balancing action with complex dramatic performances, Pitt could bring a sophisticated, chilling edge to Gotham’s expanding rogues’ gallery.

His presence also signals Reeves’ ambition to elevate the sequel’s intensity with star-powered performances alongside Pattinson, Zoë Kravitz, and other returning cast members.

Industry insiders say Pitt’s involvement, even in early talks, reflects Warner Bros.’ push to make The Batman: Part II one of its marquee releases.

Fans React to the Rumors

Within minutes of the report surfacing, social media exploded with reactions from fans who believe Pitt is a perfect fit for Gotham’s psychological horror aesthetic. Many noted his past work in thrillers and dark dramas, saying his casting could deliver “one of the most compelling Batman villains in years.”

Others speculated about potential storylines — including Arkham’s descent into obsession, his connection to Gotham’s criminal underworld, and the possibility of more villains appearing alongside him.

HOLR notes that The Batman franchise has leaned heavily into grounded realism, making character-driven antagonists especially impactful.

Where the Talks Stand Now

Sources say discussions are still in the early stages, with scheduling and story details being worked out. Warner Bros. and Matt Reeves have not commented publicly on the casting buzz, but insiders believe an announcement could come once contracts are finalized.

If confirmed, Pitt would join a cast and creative team known for redefining Batman through a gritty, noir-influenced lens.

A Sequel Building Major Momentum

Between returning stars, expanding lore, and now the possibility of Brad Pitt joining as Dr. Arkham, The Batman: Part II is shaping up to be one of the most anticipated films in development. The sequel is expected to amplify the psychological depth and world-building that made the first installment a critical and commercial success.