Judge Grants Blake Lively’s Motion to Strike Deposition Transcript in Justin Baldoni Case

Key Legal Development in High-Profile Dispute

August 8, 2025: In the latest twist of the legal battle between Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni, U.S. District Judge Lewis J. Liman has granted Lively’s motion to strike a 292-page deposition transcript from the court docket. The transcript, which detailed Lively’s July 31 testimony, was uploaded under seal by Baldoni’s legal team.

Court’s Reasoning Behind the Decision

Lively’s attorneys argued the transcript was publicly filed not for legal clarity but as “fodder” for a PR-driven media campaign. Judge Liman sided with her, stating the filing served no legitimate litigation purpose and instead appeared intended to “invite public speculation and scandal.” He wrote:

“The Wayfarer Parties’ attachment of the entire, nearly 300‑page deposition … served no proper litigation purpose … and instead appears to have been intended to burden Lively … and to invite public speculation and scandal.”
“The Court has not only the power but also the responsibility to step in.”

Accusations and Counterclaims

Lively’s team had accused Baldoni’s side of orchestrating a media spectacle, including leaking details of her attire and companions during the deposition to tabloids. Baldoni’s attorneys countered, questioning why Lively would want to hide her own testimony in a lawsuit she initiated.

Ongoing Legal Battle

This ruling comes amid broader litigation in which Lively is suing Baldoni for alleged sexual harassment and retaliation during the 2024 production of It Ends With Us. Earlier, a judge dismissed Baldoni’s $400 million countersuit against Lively and her husband, Ryan Reynolds. A trial is set for March 2026 in New York, and both parties are expected to testify.

What Does This Mean?

Legal Integrity Over PR Drama: The court’s decision reinforces the principle that legal filings should serve genuine judicial purposes, not sensationalism.

Lively’s Victory: Removing the transcript limits the opposing side’s ability to manipulate public narrative with her unrefined testimony.

Battle Intensifies Ahead of Trial: With both sides gearing up for a March 2026 trial, tensions remain high and stakes remain significant.