From major setback to fresh opportunity—Haynes moves forward after filming implosion
August 27, 2025 — Todd Haynes is breathing new life into his long-stalled project: a bold, NC-17–bound romantic drama set in 1930s Los Angeles. Previously shelved when Joaquin Phoenix exited days before shooting, the film is now being revived—with Pedro Pascal reportedly in talks to fill the role.
The Project That Almost Was
Haynes had initially developed the story alongside Joaquin Phoenix and screenwriter Jon Raymond. Described as a gay romance featuring a corrupt LA cop and a Native American lover fleeing to Mexico, the screenplay was poised for an explicit and daring cinematic take on love and identity. Phoenix’s exit, mere days from shooting, caused the project to collapse entirely. Sets were built, financing was secured, and the production was moments from a green light.
Haynes Is Not Giving Up
Addressing the project’s derailment at a festival appearance, Haynes expressed ironclad optimism.
“The film itself and the script itself may resurrect in a different form someday.”
His resilience signals a desire to honor the creative effort and emotional investment that had already been made.
Pascal in the Frame
Reports have emerged suggesting Pedro Pascal—currently busy with major franchises—has been floated as a possible replacement. While industry insiders view the option as complicated due to Pascal’s schedule and the original casting of Danny Ramirez (who remains attached), the name adds momentum to speculation that the project still lives on.
What This Revival Could Mean
| Potential | Insight |
|---|---|
| Recasting with care | Bringing on a star like Pascal preserves the ambition and visibility of the original vision. |
| Creative revival | Haynes’s commitment fosters hope that the film could still get made—just in a new form. |
| Industry impact | Gartner discussions around A-list casting, queer storytelling, and resilience in film development continue. |
In Summary
Todd Haynes isn’t letting the collapse of his NC-17 1930s gay romance define the project’s fate. With Joaquin Phoenix officially out and Pedro Pascal rumored as a possible replacement, fans and industry insiders are watching to see if this ambitious film will ultimately make its way to the screen after all.
Published by HOLR Magazine