The actor shares a surprising memory from ‘Who’s the Boss’

A Casting Story Fans Never Heard Before

January 10, 2026: Tony Danza has revealed a surprising behind-the-scenes detail from the casting of Who’s the Boss, recalling that a young Alyssa Milano showed up to her audition with a black eye.

The moment, he said, immediately stood out.

How the Injury Happened

According to Danza, Milano explained that she had gotten the black eye while playing baseball. At the time, she was just a kid, and the story reflected her active, tomboy personality.

It didn’t hurt her chances—in fact, it made her more memorable.

A First Impression That Lasted

Despite the visible bruise, Danza said Milano’s confidence and charm shone through. Her energy in the room left a strong impression on the casting team, proving she had something special.

Talent mattered more than appearances.

Landing the Iconic Role

Milano ultimately won the role of Samantha Micelli, becoming one of the show’s breakout stars. Her performance helped define the series and made her a household name throughout the 1980s.

That audition changed everything.

A Look Back at a Classic Sitcom

Who’s the Boss remains a beloved television staple, remembered for its humor and progressive take on family dynamics. Stories like this offer fans a deeper glimpse into how the cast came together.

Sometimes, the best memories happen off-screen.

Why Fans Love These Stories

Behind-the-scenes anecdotes humanize famous shows, reminding audiences that even iconic moments start with ordinary experiences. Danza’s story adds another layer to the sitcom’s legacy.

It makes the past feel closer.

Final Thoughts

Tony Danza’s memory of Alyssa Milano auditioning with a black eye is a reminder that star-making moments don’t always look perfect. What mattered most was her presence—and it clearly paid off.

Sometimes, charm beats circumstance.