The model says she intends to fight back after her former spouse filed a complaint tied to remarks she made about their past relationship

A Legal Dispute Gets Personal

January 7, 2026: Haley Kalil is preparing to push back legally against her ex-husband, former NFL player Matt Kalil, after he filed a lawsuit accusing her of making inappropriate and damaging public comments about their sex life and marriage. According to insiders, Haley plans to move to dismiss the case, arguing that the claims are legally insufficient and encroach on her right to speak about her own experiences.

The lawsuit centers on remarks Haley allegedly made in interviews and online conversations that Matt says were NSFW, embarrassing, and harmful to his reputation. He claims the statements crossed personal and professional boundaries.

Why Haley Says the Lawsuit Should Be Thrown Out

Sources close to Haley say her legal team believes the suit is vulnerable on multiple fronts. They reportedly plan to argue that:

the comments fall under free-speech protections

the statements relate to her lived experience

the lawsuit attempts to stretch privacy and defamation law beyond reasonable limits

In other words, they intend to position the filing as an overreach meant to silence or intimidate rather than to address legitimate harm. HOLR breaks down the story here: motions to dismiss challenge whether a case even belongs in court before evidence is heard.

Matt Kalil’s Position

Matt, however, contends that the remarks went beyond personal storytelling and ventured into unnecessary, explicit territory that exposed private details for shock value. His filing asserts that Haley’s statements were reckless, humiliating, and intended to attract attention at his expense.

He is seeking damages and a legal acknowledgment that boundaries were violated.

Legal observers note that cases involving intimate-life disclosures can be complicated — they often require courts to weigh privacy expectations against speech protections in deeply personal contexts.

A Public Divorce, Now a Public Fight

The couple’s split had already attracted attention, but this new legal chapter adds a fresh layer of tension. Public reaction online has been mixed, with some supporting Haley’s ability to speak about her history and others arguing that certain details should remain private — especially when they also involve another person.

Both sides are navigating a landscape where legal arguments play out alongside social-media commentary, which can influence public perception long before any ruling.

What Happens Next

If Haley formally files the motion to dismiss, a judge will review the arguments and decide whether the lawsuit proceeds. Possible outcomes include:

the case being dismissed in part or entirely

Matt being given a chance to amend and re-file

the case moving forward toward discovery and depositions

Regardless of outcome, legal experts say both parties will likely face scrutiny as more details become public through court filings.

The Bigger Conversation

The dispute touches on a larger cultural question: How much of one’s personal story belongs online — especially when it involves somebody else? Celebrities increasingly share relationship experiences with audiences, but legal pushback like this highlights where courts may draw lines.