New casting buzz suggests Johansson could join the noir-driven Gotham saga as anticipation builds for Matt Reeves’ highly awaited sequel.

Robert Pattinson

December 4, 2025: Robert Pattinson’s return as the brooding Dark Knight in The Batman: Part II is already one of the most anticipated comic-book events of the decade — and new reports suggest the sequel may introduce Scarlett Johansson as a major addition to the cast. While Warner Bros. has yet to confirm the news, industry insiders claim Johansson is in early discussions to join the film in a significant role, sparking intense speculation across the DC fandom.

Johansson’s Potential Role Sparks Major Excitement

If cast, Johansson would step into one of the darkest, most grounded versions of Gotham ever put on screen. Known for her emotional range and commanding presence, she would bring added depth to the gritty narrative world director Matt Reeves has crafted.

Fans have already begun debating which iconic character she could portray, especially given Reeves’ commitment to realistic, psychologically layered figures.

Fan Theories Surrounding Johansson’s Character

With no official announcement, theories are taking over social media and fan forums. The most popular possibilities include:

Poison Ivy – A grounded, eco-terrorist reinterpretation fits Reeves’ noir tone and would provide riveting conflict with Pattinson’s Batman.

A new femme-fatale crime figure – Someone tied to Gotham’s underworld, introducing fresh dynamics to the franchise.

A political power player – Potentially connected to Gotham’s justice system or mayoral landscape.

While Zoë Kravitz is expected to return as Selina Kyle, Johansson’s potential role appears intended to expand — not replace — the existing character roster.

Why Johansson Joining the Franchise Would Be Significant

Her involvement would mark a major shift for the actress, who spent over a decade as Black Widow in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Entering DC’s darker, more dramatic Gotham would highlight a new creative chapter for Johansson while giving The Batman franchise another A-list performer.

For Warner Bros., this casting rumor signals the studio’s ambition to elevate The Batman: Part II into one of its biggest prestige-driven comic films.

The Batman: Part II Continues Reeves’ Gritty Vision

Pattinson will reprise his role as a younger, emotionally volatile Bruce Wayne still shaping his identity as Gotham’s vigilante. The sequel is expected to dig deeper into the city’s corruption, criminal networks, and psychological warfare — hallmarks of Reeves’ approach.

Key returning cast members likely include:

Jeffrey Wright as James Gordon

Colin Farrell as Oswald “The Penguin” Cobblepot

Andy Serkis as Alfred Pennyworth

The film will also benefit from the expanded universe introduced through The Penguin spin-off series, which further develops Gotham’s shifting power structures.

Fans Await Official Confirmation

Although Scarlett Johansson’s casting has not been finalized publicly, the excitement surrounding the possibility shows how much momentum already surrounds The Batman: Part II. With production expected to begin in 2026, fans hope Warner Bros. will announce the confirmed cast in the coming months.