Simon Cowell Says He’s “Sorry” for “Being a Dick” on American Idol: “I Changed Over Time”

Cowell Reflects on His Infamously Tough Television Persona

December 1, 2025: Simon Cowell is revisiting his early days on American Idol with surprising honesty, admitting that he now feels “sorry” for how harsh he was toward contestants. Known for his cutting critiques and blunt delivery, the music mogul says that with time — and a lot of self-reflection — he realizes he often crossed the line.

“I Was a Dick… I Can See That Now”

Cowell openly acknowledged that his early approach leaned too heavily on shock value and bluntness. He explained that, at the time, he believed brutal honesty was the most effective way to push contestants and entertain viewers. Looking back, he can see how some comments were unnecessarily harsh.
He admitted that hearing old clips today makes him cringe: “Some of those things… yeah, I was a dick.”

Experience, Age, and Fatherhood Changed His Perspective

Cowell noted that becoming a father softened him in ways he didn’t anticipate. As he grew older — and more aware of the pressures young performers face — he began to shift his tone on his later shows, including The X Factor and America’s Got Talent.
He said he now understands that criticism can be firm without being cruel, and that compassion creates better performances than humiliation ever could.

Fans React With Mixed Emotions

Cowell’s comments sparked conversation across social media. Many viewers appreciated his willingness to take accountability, while others joked that his famously sharp critiques were part of what made American Idol iconic.
Still, even longtime fans acknowledged that today’s TV landscape is different — and Cowell’s earlier style would likely draw far more backlash in 2025.

A Softer, More Supportive Cowell Has Emerged

Those who’ve followed his career closely have already noticed that Cowell has toned down his on-air persona. Instead of simply cutting contestants down, he now focuses on constructive feedback, encouragement, and mentoring.
He emphasized that he’s not ashamed of where he started — but he’s proud of how he has grown.

A Reminder That Even TV’s Toughest Judge Can Evolve

Cowell’s candid apology reflects not just personal change, but a shift in how talent shows approach criticism, mental health, and vulnerability. He says he hopes his evolution shows that people can change — even those who built careers on being unapologetically harsh.