The Tony winner Cynthia Eriv faces backlash from some Christian groups over her bold portrayal in the iconic musical.

Cynthia Erivo Sparks Debate with Bold New Role

August 7, 2025: Acclaimed actress and singer Cynthia Erivo is under fire from conservative Christian circles following her portrayal in a reimagined version of Jesus Christ Superstar. Some critics have gone as far as labeling the performance “demonic,” sparking a heated debate online.

A Bold Artistic Interpretation

Erivo, known for her powerhouse vocals and emotionally charged performances, plays a central role in the updated production of the classic Andrew Lloyd Webber rock opera. The creative team behind the show aimed to modernize and diversify the casting and narrative—but not everyone is on board with the changes.

Backlash from Conservative Christians

Several conservative religious groups have taken to social media to condemn the production, calling it “blasphemous” and “an attack on Christian values.” Their criticism mostly targets the show’s artistic liberties, including gender-fluid costume design, modern symbolism, and interpretive choreography.

Support from the Entertainment Community

Despite the backlash, Erivo has received a wave of support from fans and fellow artists who praise her for pushing boundaries and embracing creative freedom. Many argue that the theater has always been a place for bold experimentation and cultural reflection.

Erivo Has Yet to Respond

As of now, Cynthia Erivo has not issued a public statement regarding the controversy, choosing instead to let her performance speak for itself.