Blake Lively Can Still Pursue Emotional Distress Claim Against Justin Baldoni Despite Dropping Two Lawsuit Counts

June 11, 2025: In a twist to the ongoing legal dispute between Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni, reports reveal that although Lively recently dropped two of her original claims, she can still pursue a case for emotional distress. The case, which made headlines earlier this year due to its high-profile nature, remains active in court despite the narrowed focus.

What Claims Were Dropped?

According to court documents, Lively has withdrawn two specific causes of action — including a defamation-related charge — in her ongoing lawsuit. While this move has led some to speculate about the strength of her case, legal experts note that dropping claims is often a strategic choice aimed at strengthening a more focused argument in court.

Emotional Distress Still on the Table

Sources close to the proceedings confirm that Lively’s legal team will still move forward with the emotional distress component of the case. This means she can argue that Baldoni’s alleged actions caused her significant psychological harm, even if the original charges have shifted.

Emotional distress claims often hinge on proving that the defendant’s behavior was extreme or outrageous enough to cause mental suffering — a high bar, but not an impossible one, especially in high-profile celebrity legal battles.

Legal Experts Weigh In

Attorneys not involved in the case say this kind of legal adjustment is common. “Dropping claims doesn’t mean the case is weak,” one legal analyst explained. “It often means the plaintiff is zeroing in on what’s most likely to win in court.”

Others believe the emotional distress angle could be compelling, depending on the evidence Lively’s team presents in the coming months.

Justin Baldoni’s Countersuit Looms

This update comes shortly after Baldoni filed a massive $400 million countersuit against Lively, accusing her of defamation and damage to his reputation. That suit remains active and may complicate or delay further hearings on Lively’s distress claim.

So far, Baldoni has not publicly commented on the dropped claims or the emotional distress allegation still on the table.

What’s Next?

As the legal drama unfolds, fans and media alike are closely watching to see how the court will handle Lively’s emotional distress claims and Baldoni’s high-value countersuit. It’s clear the case is far from over — and more legal fireworks may be ahead.